Episode 2: Ponzi Goes to Florida

Episode 2: Ponzi Goes to Florida


In 1925, a promoter offered Florida land near Jacksonville for ten dollars and promised 200% in sixty days. The land was 65 miles away, much of it was underwater, and the promoter was Charles Ponzi. Title agent and attorney John Yonas explains how the man whose name became the word for fraud tried it again in Florida real estate, and the one question that would have stopped his buyers cold: what exactly did you buy?

Episode summary

Charles Ponzi’s 1920 postal-coupon scheme made his name a synonym for fraud. Five years later, he was out on bail while appealing a Massachusetts conviction, and he went to Jacksonville in the middle of the great Florida land boom.

In this episode:

  • The setup: How Ponzi arrived in Jacksonville in September 1925 using the alias Charles Borelli, then formed the Charpon Land Syndicate.
  • How the scam worked: One hundred acres in rural Columbia County, bought at about $16 an acre, divided into 23 lots per acre and sold at $10 each, along with a promise of 200% in sixty days.
  • Here’s the Red Flag: Five questions a title professional would ask, starting with the most important: did you get a deed, or a piece of paper promising one?
  • The people on the other side of the table: How the speculative mania of the 1920s made basic due diligence feel unnecessary.
  • Follow the money: Why a fraud that collected only about $7,000 is still worth studying.
  • What got him caught: A Duval County indictment, a Florida conviction, an escape attempt as a crewman on a ship bound for Italy, and the one thing Ponzi couldn’t stop telling people.
  • The Predator Score: 20 out of 30.

Before You Buy Vacant Land: A Title Professional’s Checklist

From To Catch a Real Estate Predator, Episode 2: Ponzi Goes to Florida Prepared by American Homeland Title Agency

In 1925, Charles Ponzi sold Florida lots “near Jacksonville.” They were actually 65 miles away, and much of the land was underwater. The basic rule hasn’t changed in 100 years: don’t buy the brochure. Buy the property, and make sure they’re the same thing.

Work through each section before you sign anything or send any money. If you can’t check an item off, find out why before you go any further.

1. What exactly are you buying?

  • I will receive a deed to a specific parcel. It is not a certificate, membership, investment unit, “reservation,” or promise to convey land later.
  • I have read the purchase contract and know exactly which instrument I’ll receive at closing (general warranty deed, limited warranty deed, quitclaim deed, and so on).
  • If the deal is a land installment contract (seller financing where the deed transfers only after the final payment), I understand that I won’t hold title until I’ve paid in full. I’ve had that contract reviewed by an attorney.
  • The contract identifies the property by legal description and parcel number, not just an address, a lot name, or “near [city].”

2. Does the lot legally exist?

  • The parcel number appears on the county auditor’s
  • If the lot comes from a subdivision or a split, there is a recorded plat or an approved lot split on file with the county recorder.
  • The required planning or zoning authority approved the split. Lines drawn on a sales map don’t create legal parcels.
  • The lot can be conveyed on its own and meets minimum lot-size requirements for its zoning.

3. Who owns it, and what’s attached to it?

  • I’ve received a title commitment from a title agency I chose.
  • The seller in the contract is the same person or entity shown as owner of record.
  • I’ve reviewed the commitment’s requirements and exceptions, including:
    • Mortgages, judgments, and mechanics’ liens
    • Unpaid or delinquent real estate taxes and special assessments
    • Easements (utility, pipeline, drainage, access)
    • Deed restrictions, covenants, and HOA requirements
    • Oil, gas, or mineral rights that were severed or reserved
  • Ohio farmland: if the parcel is enrolled in CAUV (Current Agricultural Use Valuation), I know whether my plans will trigger a recoupment charge. That charge equals the prior three years of tax savings, and it becomes a lien on the land (Hancock County Auditor; Ohio Department of Taxation).

4. Where is it, and can you actually use it?

Access

  • The parcel touches a public road, or has a recorded access easement that I’ve read.
  • I can physically reach the property, not just on paper.

Buildability

  • I’ve confirmed the zoning and that my intended use is permitted.
  • I’ve checked setbacks, minimum frontage, and any building or driveway permit requirements.

Flood and wetlands

Soil, water, and sewer

  • I’ve reviewed soil suitability, including for septic, in the USDA Web Soil Survey. Soil maps are only a starting point, and a site-specific evaluation is still needed (USDA NRCS).
  • If there’s no public sewer, I’ve contacted the county health department about site evaluation and septic permit requirements.
  • I know where water will come from (public water, or a well) and what the hookup or drilling will cost.
  • Electric, gas, and internet service are available, or I know what extending them will cost.

Boundaries

  • I’ve ordered a boundary survey, or reviewed a recent one, showing corners, encroachments, and access.
  • I’ve walked the property in person, or sent someone I trust.

5. What happens at closing?

  • I know who is preparing the deed and where it will be recorded.
  • I know who is examining title and who is issuing the owner’s title insurance policy, including the name of the underwriter behind it.
  • I chose the title agency myself, and I’ve confirmed it’s licensed. I’m not relying only on a company the seller or promoter recommended.
  • Before sending money, I’ll confirm wiring instructions by phone with my title agency, using a number I looked up myself. I won’t use a number from an email.
  • After closing, I’ll confirm the deed was actually recorded in my name.

Walk away, or slow down, if you hear any of these

  • “You have to decide today.” Or any deadline that leaves no time for title work.
  • A guaranteed return, or a projected profit measured in weeks.
  • “Near [city]” with no parcel number or legal description.
  • You’ll receive a certificate, unit, or membership instead of a deed.
  • The seller won’t let you choose your own title company, attorney, or surveyor.
  • The price is far above what the county auditor’s records and nearby sales would suggest.
  • Pressure not to visit the property before you buy.

Wiring instructions that arrive by email, or change at the last minute.